Sutter’s Mill Restaurant Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing Sutter’s Mill Restaurant - a steakhouse, cocktail bar, and seafood spot in Simi Valley, CA. Offering a wide range of amenities from reservations, takeout, delivery, to vegetarian options and ADA-compliant facilities, this restaurant is a go-to for diverse dining needs. The Sutter's Gold Miner Specials feature mouth-watering signature steaks like the USDA Prime sirloin. The menu also boasts delectable options like Miners Dip, Chicken Piccata, and Baby Back Ribs. Customers rave about the juicy prime rib, tender steaks, and flavorful sides like baked potatoes and green beans. The ambiance exudes an old-school charm, making it a perfect spot for both casual dining and special occasions. With friendly service, reasonable prices, and delicious food, Sutter’s Mill Restaurant offers a memorable dining experience for all.
Sutter's Gold Miner Specials
Sutter's Signature Steak
our most popular steak since 1958 USDA Prime center cut Top Sirloin
Sutter's Cut Signature Steak
Miners Dip
6 oz. of our Prime Rib sliced thin and stacked on our garlic toast, served with horseradish & au jus
Chicken Breast
8 oz. BBQ or lemon/garlic
Chicken Piccata
thin sliced breast sautéed with capers, mushrooms & lemon
Baby Back Pork Ribs
one lb rack with our BBQ sauce slow cooked and finished on our grill
Ground Beef Steak
10 oz of 100% CAB ground chuck, fresh never frozen
Breaded Shrimp
four jumbo (8 oz,) deep fried shrimp
Salmon Fillet
8 oz. North Atlantic fillet lemon garlic or teriyaki
Main
Sutter's Steakhouse Burgers
Hamburger
5 oz. patty
Wally Burger
10 oz. patty stuffed with cheddar cheese
Cheeseburger
5 oz. patty
Garden Salad
romaine & iceberg lettuce, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms, cucumbers, carrots, green onions & bacon bits served with a small order of garlic toast
Garden Salad
A La Carte Sides
Stuffed Baked Potato
Plain Baked Potato
French Fries
Zucchini or Asparagus
Mac N Cheese
Dinner Salad or Soup
Deep Fried Cheesecake
Chocolate Cake
New York Cheesecake
Strawberry Cheesecake
Hot Fruit Cobbler
Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
Desserts
Appetizers
Sutter's Mill Garlic Toast
Goes great as an appetizer or with your soup or salad
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
topped with parmesan cheese
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Melted Cheese Toast
Shrimp Cocktail Supreme
three jumbo shrimp cut into bite size pieces in our zesty cocktail sauce
Prime Rib
slow roasted to insure exceptional tenderness and flavor; Larger cuts are available at $6 for each 4 oz. increment
Miner's Cut
slow roasted to insure exceptional tenderness and flavor; Larger cuts are available at $6 for each 4 oz. increment
Filet Mignon
6 oz tenderest of all steaks
Sutter's Cut Ribeye
14 oz. tender & full of flavor
Porterhouse Steak
20 oz. cut - the king of steaks
Ribeye Steak
9 oz tender and full of flavor
New York Steak
14 oz. center cut
Sutter's Filet Mignon
8 oz. tenderest of all steaks
Steaks and Prime Rib
Seafood
Alaskan Halibut Fillet
Pan Seared Scallops
8 oz. with a lemon sauce
Maine Lobster Tail
12 oz. cold water tail
Alaskan King Crab
Australian Lobster Tail
8 oz. cold water tail
Steak & Scallops
three jumbo pan seared scallops
Steak & Shrimp
3 jumbo deep fried shrimp